What to Put on a Turkey Sandwich: 65 Epic ideas!

If turkey is your go-to sandwich builder for making a healthy school lunch, I get you! I love it because so many things go with it and lunch is never boring!

Learn how to make your next turkey sandwich epic with these 65 add-ons and condiments for unlimited combinations.

a collage of turkey sandwiches with different things put in them

Start with your choice of turkey and bread, and fill it with these delicious options for an amazing turkey sandwich:

Best Cheese for a Turkey Sandwich

American: melty, traditional cheese and turkey sandwiches are a classic for a reason.
Mozzarella: creamy, sweet flavor that tastes delicious with hearty sliced turkey.
Provolone: salty with a sweet finish for epic sandwiches.
Pepperjack: creamy cheese with peppers will add a little peppery flavor to a turkey sandwich.
Swiss: full of buttery flavor for your sandwich enjoyment.
Gouda: creamy and has a sharper taste for sandwiches.
Monterey Jack: similar consistency to Pepperjack Cheese without the added spice!
Cream Cheese: pair with sliced tomato and pepper. You’ll thank me later.
Blue Cheese Crumbles: if this is your jam, add this sharp and fragrant cheese!
Feta: the perfect pairing for a Mediterranean-style turkey sandwich.

Turkey Sandwich Condiments

Mayo: more than likely, this is already in your fridge, waiting to be used on a turkey sandwich. Destiny!
Mustard: regular or Dijon mustard are great options for a quick lunch time sandwich.
Relish: pickley spread for a rich to crunchy flavor on your sandwich.
Salsa: your favorite salsa can bring new life to your sandwich recipes.
Sriracha: spicy turkey sandwiches will knock off your socks.
Salt & Pepper: seems basic but will add a little bit of flavor to the classic you love.
Salad Dressings: your favorite dressings (Balsamic, Ranch, Italian) can create a delicious turkey sandwich. If packing for lunch, use a separate container to avoid soggy bread.
Olive Oil: healthier alternative to salad dressing, but equally as delicious.
Tzatziki: this delicious sauce is perfect for dipping or spreading on your turkey sandwich.
Pesto: buttery and basily pesto on a turkey sandwich is flagrant and super satisfying.

Best Veggies for a Turkey Sandwich

Shredded Lettuce: use store bought packs of lettuce or chop up some romaine hearts to fill your sandwich.
Cucumber Slices: thinly slice for a light and refreshing crunch.
Shredded Carrots: sneak more veggies into you or your family’s sandwiches with this vegetastic idea.
Spinach: fresh spinach pairs the best with this combination.
Tomato: sliced tomato yields delicious texture to a turkey sandwich.
Pickles: crunchy pickles meet soft and savory sandwiches…what more could you want?
Avocado: avocado tastes amazing, and you won’t have to pay an arm & a leg for it at home!
Guacamole: you’ll love the incredible flavor it spreads into sandwiches.
Grilled Onion: leftover onions from dinner? Fill your sandwich with these delicious grilled veggies.
Red Onion: a bit stronger and more oniony, but still tasty and mouthwatering.
Shallot: similar to a regular onion, but with a more subtle flavor for less onioney sandwiches.
Jalapeño: fresh or pickled are amazing flavor enhancers for dull turkey sandwiches.
Banana Peppers: for a sweet peppery taste, try topping with banana peppers.
Olives: creates muffuletta-style sandwiches.
Bell Pepper: red, green, or yellow bell peppers add so much veggie flavor to a turkey sandwich.
Mushrooms: thinly sliced mushrooms add the right amount of flavor that enhance sandwiches.
Garlic: pickled garlic is a turkey sandwich staple because it creates an outstanding crunch with subtle garlic flavor.
Corn: delicious, crunchy, and full of fiber for a veggie filled lunch.
Artichoke: fresh spinach and artichoke is a match made in turkey sandwich heaven.

Added Protein

Bacon: mmmmm crispy and mouthwatering bacon AND turkey!
Pastrami: a mixture of smoked sausage and roast beef flavor for a more desirable turkey sandwich.
Pepperoni: pepperoni is inexpensive and creates a sandwich full of pizza flavor.
Salami: thin-sliced salami is peppery, flavorful, and mouthwatering on a turkey sandwich.
Ham: ham is a staple, so why not fill your sandwich with your favorite deli-style ham?
Roast Beef: roast beef holds a smoky flavor for flavor packed sandwiches.
Smashed Chickpeas: recreate this smashed chickpea sandwich and simply add your delicious, sliced turkey!
Mashed Beans: any beans will do for a savory bean spread. Heat up canned beans and mash for a quick and flavorful turkey sandwich filling.
Fried Egg: fried eggs are loaded with protein for a thick and filling turkey sandwich.
Hummus: use your favorite local grocery store option or make your own sandwich spread.

More Turkey Sandwich Toppings

Chips: have you ever tried this? Top with your choice of crunchy chips for a crunchy turkey sandwich.
Egg Salad: full of creamy and high protein flavor to bring your sandwich to a new level.
Coleslaw: similar to a Reuben sandwich, only better.
Chili: leftover chili finds new life in your next turkey sandwich.
Cranberry Sauce: leftover holiday sauce can be reimagined into a delicious sandwich.
Crispy Onions: for a crispy crunchy sandwich, add some onion strings.
Tzatziki: this delicious sauce is perfect for dipping or spreading on your turkey sandwich.
Pesto: buttery and basily pesto is flagrant and super satisfying.
Sun–Dried Tomatoes: pairs wonderfully with the savory turkey flavor.
Strawberries: thinly slice for a subtly sweet combination.
Apple Slices: another semi sweet combination that compliments the blandest sandwiches.
Mixed Nuts: cashews, sunflower seeds, walnuts, or your choice!